تعويض ضحايا حوادث المرور عن ضررهم المهني والاقتصادي: دراسة مقارنة

Esraa Shukry Salman  Abu Mukho

doi:10.35516/law.v50i4.1413

Authors

Esraa Shukry Salman Abu Mukho Department of Private Law, Faculty of Law, Al-Quds University, Palestine. https://orcid.org/0000-0003-0183-1829

DOI:

https://doi.org/10.35516/law.v50i4.1413

Keywords:

Damage, compensation, accidents, Palestine, Tunisia, insurance law

Abstract

Objectives: This study aims to shed light on the Palestinian Insurance Law No. (20) of 2005 and the Tunisian Insurance Journal No. (86) of 2005. It particularly investigates the extent to which the legislators achieve their goal of adopting a new system based on impartial regulations to ensure fair and equitable compensations to all those affected by road accidents.

Methods: The study uses the comparative and analytical approach to examine the Palestinian and Tunisian insurance laws as well as the decisions of the Palestinian and Tunisian Courts of Cassation.

Results: The study concludes that several articles of the Palestinian and Tunisian insurance laws support the insurer at the expense of the insured, particularity in relation to the compensations available for the occupational damage of road accident victims. Moreover, the study reveals that the Palestinian and Tunisian insurance laws in 2005 are not fair when it comes to compensating for the moral and financial damages upon the death of the insured in a road accident. Limiting the list of those who are entitled to compensations of this sort, whether in the Tunisian Insurance Journal or the Palestinian Insurance Law, is a clear violation of the legal goals of 2005.

Conclusions: The legal goals of 2005 which aim to expand compensation coverage by ensuring fair compensation have not been fulfilled.

Downloads

Download data is not yet available.

References

Abdel Rahman, A. (1999). The extent of compensation for the change of damage to the victim's body and money in civil, contract and tort liability. , Al-Iskanria: Mansha'at Al-Maaref.

Abu Hamad, R. (2018). Civil liability arising from road accidents, and compulsory insurance, including a comparative study., (Master’s thesis, An-Najah National University,). Palestine

Abu Hilal, M. (2016). A critical study of the provisions on vehicle insurance contained in the Palestinian Insurance Law No. 20 of 2005., (Master's thesis, Al-Quds University,). Palestine.

Ahmed, I. (2003). Mediator in compensation cases and the liability of insurance companies in car accidents, in knowledge and in practice. Egypt: House of Legal Books.

Al Bakri, M. (2016). Compensation Claim., Cairo: Mahmoud Publishing House.

Al-Auji, M. (2004). Civil Law - Part Two Civil Liability. -, Beirut: Al-Halabi Human Rights Publications.

Al-Barawi, H. (2009). Compensating natural and moral persons for moral damage: (an applied study of modern forms of harm.), Cairo: Dar Al-Nahda Al-Arabiya.

Al-Khashnawi, C. (2016). The Crossroads, an applied reading of the Law on Compensation for Damage to Persons in Traffic Accidents (Law No. 86 of 15 August 2005),.Tunisia: Sanabel Publishing House.

Al-Khelaifi, F. (2007). The Right to Litigation. , Journal of the Judiciary and Legislation, No. 8, October 2007, Center for Legal and Judicial Studies, Tunis,: Ministry of Justice, 8.

Al-Mousa, R. (2018). The summary in explaining the provisions of the Palestinian Insurance Law No. 20 of 2005., Palestine: Comprehensive Publishing and Distribution.

Al-Sanhoury, A. (1952). The mediator in explaining the civil law: The Theory of Commitment in General: Sources of Commitment.., Beirut: House of Revival of Arab Heritage.

Al-Suhaimi, S. (2015). A new reading of the law on compensation for damages resulting from traffic accidents.., Tunisia: Publications of Majma al-Atrash for specialized writers.

Aweidah, N. (2008). Provisions of the Palestinian Insurance Law No. 20 of 2005., Gaza: Dar Al-Manara Press.

Ben Ali, T. (1964). Civil Liability in Road Accidents.., Tunisia: Tunisian Company for Graphic Arts.

Bou Aziz, H. (2017). Jurisprudence of Traffic Accidents Judiciary for the years 2006-2011, a legal article within the jurisprudence related to the 2005 law on compensation in the matter of traffic accidents, Association of Jurists in Sfax. , Tunisia: Al-Atrash Complex for the publication and distribution of the specialized book.

Diane, B. (2001). « Traite de droit civil, les effets de la responsabilité. », 2nded, L.G.D.J., Paris: Dalloz.

Duroy, D. (1973). Un lien juridique avec la victime directe n'est pas nécessaire pour permettre indirectement à la victime d'obtenir réparation, R.T.D civil. Paris: Dalloz.

Jabr, A. (1998). Rebound damage and compensation in tort., Amman: Dar Al Thaqafa Library for Publishing and Distribution.

Kahlon, A. (2017). Traffic Accidents Compensation Case. , Tunisia: Al-Atrash Complex for Specialized Books.

Khater, N. (22009). Explanation of Civil Law Sources of Personal Rights. , Amman: House of Culture for Publishing and Distribution.

Masudi, S. (2015). Compensation for bodily damages resulting from road accidents under the Palestinian Insurance Law. , (Master's Thesis, Al-Quds University,). Palestine.

Mimouni, M. (2014). The Family’s Right to Compensation for Reciprocal Damage,. Morocco: Knowledge Publishing House.

Morcos, S. (1998). Al-Wafi in Explanation of Civil Law, vol.2, on harmful act and civil liability - Section One - in general provisions. Beirut: House of Human Rights Publications.

Nakshabandi, M.(2007) Casualties and deaths from road traffic accidents in dohuk Dohuk College of Medicine. (PhD thesis, University of Dohuk). Iraq.

Savatier, R. (1959). Les métamorphoses économique et sociales du droit privé d’aujourdhui, T63.(63rd ed.). Paris: Editions LHarmattan.

Shukri, B (2007). Insurance in Application, Law and the Judiciary., Cairo: House of Culture for Publishing and Distribution.

Taha, C. (2010). The Basis of Civil Liability for Unlawful Action between Error and Damage, A Comparative Study in Islamic Sharia and Man-made Laws., Egypt: Dar Shatat for Publishing and Software.