التنظيم القانوني للاستئناف التبعي في قانون أصول المحاكمات الشرعية الأردني رقم (31) لسنة 1959 المعدل بالقانون رقم (11) لسنة 2016: دراسة مقارنة

Raed Lutfi Mahmoud  Soboh

doi:10.35516/law.v50i4.2318

Authors

Raed Lutfi Mahmoud Soboh Department of Comparative Law, Sheikh Noah Al-Qudah Faculty of Sharia and Law, The World Islamic Sciences and Education University, Jordan https://orcid.org/0009-0009-3575-4498

DOI:

https://doi.org/10.35516/law.v50i4.2318

Keywords:

Appeal, collateral appeal, sharia procedure code

Abstract

Objectives: This study sheds light on the collateral appeals submitted to the Jordanian Sharia Courts of Appeal in accordance with the Sharia Procedure Law. A collateral appeal gives the respondent the right to respond to the original appeal even after the expiry date of filing an appeal.

Methods: The study uses the analytical approach to review the legal texts governing collateral appeals in the Sharia Procedure Code and to compare them with comparative law and jurisprudence.

Results: The results show that the collateral appeal is an ordinary appeal by which the respondent responds to an appeal made by the appellant after the appeal’s deadline. The study also reveals that the collateral appeal either follows the usual procedures and general rules of the original appeal (whether it has been filed or not) or is filed with a written memorandum containing the reasons for the appeal. This process takes place within ten days following the date of notifying the respondent of the original appeal list.

Conclusions: This study recommends that collateral appeals should be exempted from fees, whether they respond to original appeals or merely adhere to their rules.

Downloads

Download data is not yet available.

References

Abu al-Wafa, A. (1984). Commentary on the Texts of the Code of Procedure. (4th ed.). Alexandria: Knowledge Establishment.

Abu Eid, A. (2004). Civil Procedure. (1st ed.). Lebanon: Al-Halabi Human Rights Publications.

Adalah Center Publications

Adam, S. (2021). The system of government in the Sultanate of Wadi (1615-1900) AD. Journal of Humanities and Social Sciences, 5(14).

Adewale, L. (2020). Description of Sharia Judiciary in the Nigerian Constitution Constitution of the Federal Republic of Nigeria in 1999 AD descriptive and analytical study. Comprehensive Multidisciplinary Electronic Journal, 27.

AL-hussayn. P. (2020). The relationship of Islamic jurisprudence with law in the Kingdom of Saudi Arabia: an analytical study. Scientific Journal of King Faisal University, 21(2).

Al-Kilani, M. (2006). Explanation of the provisions of the Code of Procedure of Procedure.

Al-Mashaqi, H. (2011). Brief explanation of the Palestinian Code of Civil Procedure No. 2 of 2001. (1st ed.). Culture House for Publishing and Distribution.

Al-Nahi, P. (1983). Brief on the Principles of Judicial Organization, Litigation and Pleadings in the Hashemite Kingdom of Jordan. Al-Mahd House for Publishing and Distribution.

Alqudah, M. (2013). The Origins of Civil Trials and Judicial Organization. (2nd ed.). Dar Al Thaqafa for Publishing and Distribution.

Antioch, R. (1982). Origins of Trials in Civil and Commercial Materials. Cooperative Press.

Carpenter, A. E., Mark, A., Shanahan, C. F., & Steinberg, J. K. (2022). The field of state civil courts. Colum. L. Rev., 122, 1165.

Engstrom, D. F. (2013). The Twiqbal puzzle and empirical study of civil procedure. Stan. L. Rev., 65, 1203.

Fahmy, R. (1994). Principles of the Kuwaiti Urban Judiciary: According to the New Cranes Law. (2nd ed.). Dar Al Kitab Foundation.

Fouda, P. (2010). The Modern Encyclopedia in Commentary on the Code of Civil and Commercial Procedure. (6th ed.). International Bureau of Legal Encyclopedias.

Jordanian Code of Civil Procedure No. 24 of 1988 and its amendments

Jordanian Sharia Court Fees System No. (61) of 2015

Journal of the Bar Association

Lebanese Code of Procedure No. 90 of 01983

Mahmoud, A. (2008). Explain the law of they and for Sharia trials. Modern Institution.

Malkawi, M., & Mansour, B. (2008). Explain the texts of the Jordanian Code of Civil Procedure. (1st ed.). Wael Publishing House.

Mckenzie , T, (2010). Judicial independence, autonomy, and bankruptcy. Stanford law review, 62(3), 747-808.

Mubarak , p. (2012). The origins of litigation in the United Arab Emirates. (2nd ed.). Bright horizons.

Muslim, A. (n.d). The Origins of the Pleadings. Dar al-Fikr al-Arabi, and Egypt.

Omar, A., & Ahmed, E. (2004). Code of Civil Procedure (Lebanese). (1st ed.). Al-Halabi publications.

Omar, N. (2011). Mediator in the Code of Civil and Commercial Procedure. New University House.

Qandil, M. (2011). Brief in the judiciary and litigation in accordance with the Civil Procedure Law of the United Arab Emirates. (1st ed.). Bright horizons.

Ragheb, W. (1986). Principles of civil justice. (1st ed.). Dar AlFikr Alarabi.

Sahouri, T. (2016). Legal Amendments to the Jordanian Law of Sharia Procedure No. 31 of 1959 under Law No. 11 of 2016, Original Study. PhD Dissertation, International Islamic Floating University, Amman.

Saif, R. (1970). Mediator in explaining the law of civil and commercial procedure. (9th ed.). Dar Al Nahda for Arabia.

Sawi, A. (2004). Mediator in explaining the law of civil and commercial procedure. Dar Al-Fikr Al-Arabi.

Shoshari, P. (2010). Explain Jordan's Code of Civil Procedure. (1st ed.). Dar Al Thaqafa for Publishing and Distribution.

Students, A. (2003). Appeal and petition for review. Legal Books House.

Students, A. (2010). Encyclopedia of Civil and Commercial Proceedings. (4th ed.). Egyptian Book House

The Jordanian Code of Sharia Procedure No. (31) of 1959 and amendments.

UAE Code of Civil Procedure No. (11) of 1992

Wally, F. (1993). Mediator in the Civil Judiciary. Cairo University and the University Book.

Wally, F. (2001). Mediator in the Civil Judiciary Law. (2nd ed.). Arab Renaissance House.

Zoubi, P. (2003). The Origins of Civil Trials, Part 2, Litigation – Judgments and Methods of Appeal. Wael Publishing House.

Zoubi, P. (2010). Dropping and dropping the litigation in accordance with the Jordanian Code of Civil Procedure. Dirasat: Shari'a and Law Sciences, 37(1).

Zoubi, P. (2013). Legal Controls for Consequential Appeal According to the Jordanian Code of Civil Procedure. Dirasat: Sharia Sciences and Law, University of Jordan, 40(2).