The Degree of Commitment of States Parties in Responding to the Requests for Cooperation from the International Criminal Court: Jordan as a Case Study

Authors

  • Dyala Ta’ani Department of Public Law, Faculty of Law, Yarmouk University, Jordan.
  • Ahmad Zuqaibah Department of Public Law, Faculty of Law, Yarmouk University, Jordan.

Keywords:

International Criminal Court, requests for cooperation, Assembly of States Parties, referral to the Security Council.

Abstract

This research focuses on adherence of member states to the requests for cooperation from International Criminal Court and the forms of such commitment. It also shows the legal implications of not adhereing to these requests by stating the legal responsibility of member states in the court and the extent of their obedience to its statute and the degree of referring to the Assembly of States Parties and the Security Council. The study focuced on Jordan as a member of the court’s statute when it refused to extradite former Sudanese President Omar al-Bashir and the reasons behind refusing to cooperate with the court. This indicates the insufficient number of guarantees necessary to respond and implement court decisions, including requests for cooperation, and therefore, it is necessary to amend the provisions of the court system in order to achieve the goal of its existence. The descriptive and analytical approach was used in this research. The study reached the following conclusions: the court is considered a multilateral international organization, that the cooperation of the parties with the court constitutes one of the guarantees surrounding the mandatory force of its decisions and that the lack of cooperation of the states parties with the court constitutes a major obstacle to the exercise of its jurisdiction. In addition, the Security Council is considered one of the guarantees for the implementation of the decisions of the International Criminal Court. Also, the court lacks some organs that should be subordinate to it and work according to its system and instructions.

Downloads

Download data is not yet available.

References

Abu al-Ala, A. (2008). The role of the Security Council in the maintenance of international peace and security has evolved. Egypt: New University house.

Al-hussami, S. (2019). Mechanisms for the enforcement of sentences issued by the International Criminal Court, Master's thesis, Middle East University, 105.

Atlam, Sh. (2008). International Criminal Court, constitutional and legislative Meow Matt. (5th ed.). Cairo.

Boka, M. (2014). La Cour Pénale Internationale entre droit et relations internationales, les faiblesses de la cour a l'épreuve de la politique des Etats, Thèse de doctorat, Paris-Est, sciences politiques, p.175.

D'appel, L. (2018). Situation du Darfour (Soudan), N ICC-02/05-01/09, 12 Mars 2018, p.6,7,10.

Essence, D. (2011-2012). The extent of the activation of the United Nations Organization of the International Criminal Court, Master's Thesis, University of Algiers, 6.

Faraj, P. (2017). The UN Security Council: a study in legal and political jurisdiction, manifestations of its imbalance and obstacles to its reform in light of international changes, Master's thesis, Middle East University, 17.

Hammadi, A. (2016). Cooperation with the International Criminal Court in the light of public international law: a comparative study, PhD thesis, Beirut Arab University, 6.

Hassani, Kh. (2018). The role of the powers of the Security Council in activating international cooperation with the International Criminal Court. Kuwait International Law College Journal, 4(2).

Kassem, M. (2003). The UN intervenes in armed conflicts that are not of an international character. Alexandria: new university House.

Lombat, P. (2014). Les source et fondement de l'obligation de coopérer avec Cour Penal International CPI. Revue Québécoise de droit international, p.115.

Mohara, H. (2012). The role of the Security Council in referring international crimes to the International Criminal Court, Master thesis, Middle East University, 3 .

Namwshi, P. (2018). Preliminary division of the International Criminal Court, Master's Thesis, University of Biskra, Algeria, 10.

Obaid Karim, E., and Al-Fatlawi, P. (2012). The legal nature of the International Criminal Court. Journal of politics and international, 20, 7.

Omar, J. (1998). International justice and the impact of national sovereignty in the implementation of international judgments: an analytical study of the most important international issues. Cairo: Arab renaissance House.

Pre-Trial Chamber II. (2017). Situation in Darfur, Sudan in the case of the prosecutor v. Omar Hassan Ahmad Albashir, No .ICC-.02/05-01/09-309 11-12-2017 1/22 EK PT, p.4.

Qashi, Kh. (2000). The problem of implementing the judgments of international courts between the text and reality. (1st ed.). Beirut: University Foundation for studies, publishing and distribution.

Security Council resolution 955 of 1994.

Tazi, M. (2007). The relationship of the Security Council with the International Criminal Court under the provisions of the Rome Convention 1998, Master's Thesis, University of Blida, 53.

The Appeals Chamber. (2019). Situation in Darfur,Sudan in the case of the prosecutor v. Omar Hassan Ahmad Albashir, No.ICC-025-019 QA2, p. 4.

The website of the International Criminal Court; https://www.icc-cpi.int/Pages/item.aspx, viewing date 12/2/2020.

Yobe, a. (2011-2012). Relationship of the Security Council to the International Criminal Court, PhD thesis, University of Oran, Algeria, 32.

Published

2021-06-01

How to Cite

Ta’ani, D. ., & Zuqaibah , A. . (2021). The Degree of Commitment of States Parties in Responding to the Requests for Cooperation from the International Criminal Court: Jordan as a Case Study. Dirasat: Shari’a and Law Sciences, 48(2), 30–40. Retrieved from https://dsr.ju.edu.jo/djournals/index.php/Law/article/view/2256

Issue

Section

Articles