The Fallacious Argumentation in Abdelhamid Al-Kaatib Letters  "A Letter in Chess" As a Model

صلاح الدين  دراوشة

doi:10.35516/hum.v49i6.3732

المؤلفون

صلاح الدين دراوشة جامعة زايد، دبي، الأمارات العربية المتحدة

DOI:

https://doi.org/10.35516/hum.v49i6.3732

الكلمات المفتاحية:

الحجاج، الحجاج المغالط، عبد الحميد الكاتب، الرسائل الديوانية

الملخص

تتناول هذه الدراسة موضوع المغالطات الحجاجية بصفته فرعا أصيلا من نظرية الحجاج وتحليل الخطاب؛ وتهدف إلى الوقوف على المغالطات الحجاجية التي وظفها عبد الحميد الكاتب في رسالته (رسالة في الشطرنج)، التي حرّم فيها لعب الشطرنج وعدّه من موبقات الآثام، وكبائر الذنوب، كما ضمّنها جملة من العقوبات القاسية التي فرضها الخليفة الأموي لمن لا يمتنع عن لعبها. وقد كشفت الدراسة عن مجموعة من المغالطات الحجاجية في الرسالة، مثل: مغالطة السلطة، والخطأ في الاستشهاد، والتشبيه الزائف، والمصادرة على المطلوب، ومغالطة القوة، ومغالطة التناقض. تلك المغالطات كانت تتستر خلف مقصديته المضمرة المتمثلة في صرف الناس عن الاجتماع في الأندية والمجالس كي لا تتوفر لهم الفرصة لمناقشة أمور الدولة الأموية وانتقادها.

التنزيلات

بيانات التنزيل غير متوفرة بعد.

المراجع

Abbas, Ihsan (1988). Abd al- Hamid al- Katib and the rest of his letters and those of Salem Abi Al-Ala' , (1st) , Amman: Dar Al-Shorouk.

Alaoui, Hafez. (2015). Argument and Symmetry: The Etiquette of Symmetry and Revealing the Mechanisms of Confusion in the Heritage of Ibn Hazm Al-Andalusi, Journal of King Abdulaziz University - Arts and Humanities, Kingdom of Saudi Arabia, Vol. 22.

Al-Hofy, Ahmed. (n.d). Politics Literature in the Umayyad Era, Beirut: Dar Al-Qalam.

Al-Jahiz, Abu Othman Amr bin Bahr. (1964). Al-Jahiz's Letters, investigation: Abdel Salam Haroun, Cairo: Al-Khanji Library

Al-Khudari, Muhammad. (1986) Lectures on the History of Islamic Nations - the Umayyad State, (1st), Beirut: Dar Al-Qalam - Beirut.

Al-Khwarizmi, Jamal al-Din. (1906). Mufid Al-Ulum Wa Mubid Al-humum (Beneficial for science and repellent of worries), (no edition) Cairo: Dar Al-Takadum.

Al-Nawawi, Abu Zakaria Yahya. (1994). Sahih Muslim, with the explanation of Al-Nawawi, Book of Faith, chapter of the statement of major and major sins, Hadith No. 145, 2(2), Cairo: Cordoba Foundation.

Al-Nuwari, Muhammad. (n.d). Fallacy methods, an introduction to the criticism of pilgrims, Within the book of the most important theories of pilgrims in the Western tradition from Aristotle to today, supervised by Hammadi Samoud, Tunis: University of Letters and Human Sciences.

Al-Shehri, Abdel-Hadi. (2004). Discourse Strategies - A Pragmatic Linguistic Approach, 1st Edition Beirut: United New Book House.

Al-Tanoukhi, Abu Ali Al-Mohsen. (1995). Nishwar Al-Muhadara wa Akhbar Al-mudhakara (The talk of the lecture and study news), Investigation: Abboud Al-Shalji, (2nd), Beirut: Dar Sader.

Asher, Abdel Salam. (2006). When We Communicate, We Change - A Cognitive Deliberative Approach to the Mechanisms of Argumentative Communication, (no edition) Casablanca: East Africa.

Balbaa, Eid. (2017). The argumentative fallacy in the context of martyrdom, Journal of Contexts of Language and Interdisciplinary Studies, Arab Republic of Egypt, 2( 5).

Behi, Hassan. (2004). Dialogue and Critical Thinking Methodology, (no edition) Casablanca: Africa of the East.

Behi, Hassan. (2014). Fallacies in Daily Discourse: A Pragmatic Approach, within the Book of Pragmatics - The Science of Using Language, 2nd, Irbid - Jordan: The Modern World of Books

Boughazala, Mohamed. (2019). Strategies and methods of the fallacious pilgrims in the Arab heritage, Journal of Arabic Language Sciences and Literature, Algeria, 11(2).

Dardiri, Samia. (2011).Arguments in Arabic Poetry, Its Structure and Methods, (2nd), Irbid - Jordan: The Modern World of Books.

Guest, Shawqi. (n.d). Art and its doctrines in Arabic prose, (10th), Cairo: Dar Al Maaref.

Ibn Abd Rabbo, Ahmed bin Muhammad. (1983). Al-eaqd Al-farid (The Unique Contract), Investigated by: Abdel-Majid Al-Tarhini, (1st), Beirut: Dar Al-Kutub Al-Ilmia.

Ish, Youssef. (1985). The Umayyad State and the latest developments that preceded it and paved the way for it starting from the Othman disorder, 2nd, Damascus: Dar Al-Fikr.

Jidiy, Eman and Rawabihi, Ahlam (2017). Arguments and fallacy - a pragmatic study in Surat Al-Furqan, memorandum for obtaining a master's degree in language and literature, Elaraby University - Tebessa, Algeria.

Kotal, Fadila. 3(1). (2014). The arguments of authority or the authority of arguments, Fasl Al-Khattab Journal - Al-Hajjaj Discourse Laboratory, Ibn Khaldun University, Algeria,

Mostafa, Adel. (2017). Logical Fallacies, Chapters in Non-Formal Logic, (Bi) London: Hendawi Foundation, London.

Moussalli, Abu Hafs Omar. (1342 AH). Al-Mughni ean Al-hifz wa Al-kitab (Enough about memorization and the book), Cairo: Arab Book Publishing Association.

Radi, Rashid. (2010).Arguments and Fallacies from Dialogue in Reason to Reason in Dialogue, (1st). Beirut: Dar Al-Kitab Al-Jadeed United.

Shahryar, espbad marzipan. (1997). Marzipan Namah, translated by: Shihab Al-Din Ahmed bin Muhammad bin Arab Shah, (1st).Beirut: Al-Intishar Foundation.

Solah, Abdullah (n.d.). The argument, its frameworks, premises, and techniques, Within the book of the most important theories of pilgrims in the Western tradition from Aristotle to today, supervised by Hammadi Samoud, Tunisia: University of Arts and Humanities.

Soula, Abdullah. (2011). On the Theory of Arguments - Studies and Applications, 1st Edition, Tunis: Mskeliani Publishing.

Yahya, Fatma. (2016). The Fallacy Strategy in the Arab Literary Heritage, (Bi) Algeria, Discourse Analysis Lab Publications, Mouloud Mammeri University.

Zahaf, Youssef. (2019). Argumentative fallacies and their communicative importance, Jill Journal of Literary and Intellectual Studies, Jill Center for Scientific Research, Lebanon, Year Six, No. 49.